Do Coffee Defects Affect Coffee Flavor? How to Identify Defective Coffee Beans?

Understanding Defective Coffee Beans: Should You Pick Them Out?

If you're familiar with the specialty coffee community, you likely know that defective beans can significantly impact the flavor of a cup of coffee. If you regularly purchase coffee beans to brew at home, should you specifically pick out defective beans before brewing?

The Grading System for Coffee Beans

After processing, coffee beans undergo grading procedures, with most grading systems including defect rate indicators. For example, Ethiopian Grade 1 coffee beans must have fewer than 3 defects in a 350g sample; Blue Mountain Coffee's highest grade, No. 1, requires a defect rate not exceeding 2%; and Golden Mandheling coffee beans must have a defect rate below 3%.

In other words, when purchasing higher-grade coffee beans at the raw bean level, the number of defects is typically minimal. Of course, the defective beans mentioned here usually refer to major defects that significantly affect flavor quality, such as over-fermented beans, black beans, severely insect-damaged beans, moldy beans, foreign objects, and so on.

The Bean Sorting Process

Before coffee beans enter the roasting process, they undergo a defect removal procedure. At this stage, any "escaped" defects are eliminated because even the highest-quality raw coffee beans cannot guarantee zero defects. Additionally, collision-related breakage may occur during transportation, so a more stringent defect removal process is conducted before roasting. For example, slightly insect-damaged beans, broken beans, shell beans, and moldy beans are picked out at this time.

After roasting, another selection process is required, typically removing roasting defects such as quakers and shell beans. Roasting defects generally refer to scorched beans with crater-like burn marks. Quakers are beans from unripe coffee cherries that are difficult to identify in their raw state. After roasting, quakers appear noticeably lighter in color than normal beans. They rarely appear in high-grade coffee beans processed from fully red cherries and are more commonly found in Brazilian beans (where they are selected and removed after roasting).

FrontStreet Coffee's Perspective

Therefore, through the layered screening processes during export and roasting, the vast majority of defective beans are eliminated. FrontStreet Coffee believes that if you're purchasing roasted single-origin coffee beans, you don't need to worry about defective beans affecting the coffee's flavor.

However, can such strict quality control completely achieve zero defects? Not entirely, as the removal process is still handled manually, so some inconspicuous defective beans might occasionally be missed. Additionally, after roasting and packaging, coffee beans must undergo transportation before reaching consumers, during which some beans might crack due to collisions. This won't significantly affect the coffee's flavor, but as consumers, you can also remove these obvious cracked beans during the weighing process before brewing.

Mistaken Defects: Cases Frequently Reported to FrontStreet Coffee

Of course, FrontStreet Coffee has received feedback about beans mistakenly identified as defective. Based on FrontStreet Coffee's summary, these can generally be categorized into the following types:

Type 1: Wrinkled Appearance with Dark Spots

This type of bean appearance typically occurs in washed, high-altitude, light-roasted coffee beans. High-altitude beans have higher density, so during roasting, as moisture evaporates, they shrink and develop wrinkles. Additionally, due to light roasting, the beans may finish roasting before they have fully expanded. Although these beans might look wrinkled and unattractive, they are definitely not defective, and their flavor profile presents very pleasant acidity.

Type 2: Cracked Beans

Some coffee beans appear cracked open, looking incomplete and easily mistaken for defective beans. In reality, these are also normal coffee beans. The cracking occurs because high-density coffee beans absorb and store more heat during roasting, leading to violent cracking at first crack that splits the beans open. Although they may not look aesthetically pleasing, they don't affect the coffee's flavor and may even contribute to making the coffee taste better.

Type 3: Unique Individual Appearance

Some coffee beans are very conspicuous because they look different from other coffee beans. At this point, many people might assume that different-looking beans must affect the coffee's flavor. In reality, these are not defective beans either—they just have a unique appearance. Of course, if you find them unpleasant to look at, you can always treat them as defective beans.

Important Notice :

前街咖啡 FrontStreet Coffee has moved to new addredd:

FrontStreet Coffee Address: 315,Donghua East Road,GuangZhou

Tel:020 38364473