Dark Roast vs Light Roast Coffee Beans - Differences and Pricing

Professional Coffee Knowledge Exchange | For more coffee bean information, please follow Coffee Workshop (WeChat official account: cafe_style)

Should Coffee Beans Be Dark or Light Roasted? What Are the Differences Between Dark and Light Roast Coffee Beans?

The debate over whether a particular coffee should be dark or light roasted has been quite intense within the coffee industry. Roasters who support light roasting believe that coffee beans should be lightly roasted to maximize the expression of the coffee's flavor characteristics. This is especially supported by many younger coffee roasters who are strong advocates of light roasting.

Indeed, we've noticed that with the advancement of the global specialty coffee movement, light roasting of coffee beans seems to have become the standard and trend for specialty coffee. Some specialty coffee roasters in America take light roasting to remarkably light degrees. On the other hand, supporters of dark roasting argue that coffee beans only complete the "Maillard reaction" fully after medium to dark roasting. Peet's Coffee in San Francisco has consistently maintained a dark roasting style, and they are recognized as experts in dark roasting.

The debate between dark and light roast factions will likely continue indefinitely, as the choice of coffee roast level signifies a roaster's understanding of coffee flavors. Personally, I believe that dark and light roasting neither need nor should be uniformly standardized. Roasters' understanding of coffee naturally varies greatly. Even among roasters who prefer light roasting, their roast levels and curve profiles differ significantly.

However, as roasters, the choice of roast level should not be based solely on personal interests and preferences, but rather should focus on the needs of the audience. Therefore, light roasting has its merits, and dark roasting has its advantages—there is no inherent difference in quality between them. If your customers pursue flavor complexity and wish to experience the regional characteristics of coffee's origin, then light roasting can allow them to more clearly perceive what they're seeking.

Conversely, if your customers prefer round, full-bodied coffee with rich sweetness, then medium to dark roasting would be more appropriate. However, I must speak on behalf of dark roast coffee roasters. Many light roast style roasters believe that when coffee is dark roasted, it contains nothing but bitter, burnt flavors, and that the coffee's flavor is completely lost in dark roasting. This statement is not objective. A roaster skilled in dark roasting can produce coffee that not only lacks smoky, burnt flavors but also allows customers to perceive the coffee's original characteristics. In other words, someone who only roasts coffee until it's black and oily with extremely strong smoky flavors is not a roaster but a charcoal burner.

What Are the Flavor Characteristics of Light, Medium, and Dark Roast Coffee Beans?

Generally, light roasted beans tend to highlight refreshing flavors with very rich flavor expressions. Floral notes, fruit acidity, and certain tea-like characteristics are typical flavor profiles of these beans. Medium roasting, on the other hand, presents a more balanced expression, combining both refreshing flavors and rich body. Dark roasted beans tend to emphasize their mouthfeel, with typically more intense flavors such as smoky, chocolate, and woody notes being the characteristic expressions of these beans. They are also accompanied by a heavy body.

The classification of these three roasting methods is only a very general approach. In reality, many factors such as bean origin, variety, and the roaster's style all influence the roast level. This answer is only a general statement, as roasters adjust the roast curve according to the characteristics of each individual bean. Even a difference of one degree in temperature or two seconds in timing can result in different flavor outcomes.

FrontStreet Coffee Dark Roast Coffee Bean Recommendations

FrontStreet Coffee's house-roasted dark roast coffee beans include several varieties, such as FrontStreet Coffee Honduras, FrontStreet Coffee Brazil Red Bourbon, and FrontStreet Coffee Indonesia Lintong Mandheling—all of which have excellent guarantees in terms of brand and quality. More importantly, they offer exceptional value. A half-pound (227 grams) package costs only around 80-90 RMB. Calculating at 15 grams per pour-over coffee, one package can make approximately 15 cups of coffee, with each single-origin coffee costing only about 6 RMB. Compared to café prices that often reach dozens of RMB per cup, this represents extremely high value for money, making it suitable for dark roast coffee enthusiasts to purchase and try.

FrontStreet Coffee: A roastery in Guangzhou with a small shop but diverse bean varieties, where you can find both famous and lesser-known beans. They also provide online store services: https://shop104210103.taobao.com

Important Notice :

前街咖啡 FrontStreet Coffee has moved to new addredd:

FrontStreet Coffee Address: 315,Donghua East Road,GuangZhou

Tel:020 38364473