The Impact of Blooming and Its Duration on Pour-Over Coffee (Part 2)
Last time, we used a Clever Dripper to obtain objective data about whether to bloom and for how long. We learned that as the bloom time increases, acidity decreases, while sweetness and viscosity are enhanced. The overall flavor profile gradually shifts backward and becomes more complex. From the TDS and EXT readings, we observed that as bloom time lengthens, both TDS and EXT values show a downward trend. We also mentioned that the Clever Dripper is closer to immersion brewing, so in this experiment, we'll apply the same method to a V60 dripper to see what kind of flavor profile and data it produces when using water flow agitation in this filter-style dripper.
Pour-over Experiment Design
The pour-over experiment was divided into two groups. The first group had a fixed brewing time of 2 minutes and 10 seconds, with bloom times of 0 seconds, 20 seconds, 40 seconds, and 60 seconds respectively. The second group considered that with different bloom times but the same total brewing time, when reaching 60 seconds of bloom, we would need to use a large water flow for rapid brewing to achieve the target 2 minutes and 10 seconds. This would mean that as bloom time extends, our subsequent water pouring would accelerate, and we all know that pour-over coffee with slow, fine water flow versus fast, large water flow produces very different flavor profiles. Therefore, we decided to add a second group of experiments to make the final data more objective. The second group still used bloom times of 0 seconds, 20 seconds, 40 seconds, and 60 seconds, but the total brewing time was extended accordingly as the bloom time lengthened.
Experiment Steps and Data
Pour-over Experiment 1
(Both groups of pour-over experiments used approximately 40g of water for blooming)
Experiment Steps:
- Weigh 15g of coffee beans, grind with Fuji (ghost teeth) #2 and set aside
- Prepare sufficient 90°C hot water
- A: Add 15g of coffee grounds to a Hario V60 conical dripper, continuously pour 240g of hot water in circular motion, total brewing time is 2min10s
- B: Add 15g of coffee grounds to a Hario V60 conical dripper, first pour 40g of hot water for 20-second bloom, then pour 200g of hot water in circular motion, total brewing time is 2min10s
- C: Add 15g of coffee grounds to a Hario V60 conical dripper, first pour 40g of hot water for 40-second bloom, then pour 200g of hot water in circular motion, total brewing time is 2min10s
- D: Add 15g of coffee grounds to a Hario V60 conical dripper, first pour 40g of hot water for 60-second bloom, then pour 200g of hot water in circular motion, total brewing time is 2min10s
Experiment Results:
Results Analysis:
After comparative analysis with pre-experiment predictions, we found that as bloom time increases, the changes in flavor and mouthfeel generally follow expectations, showing decreased acidity with enhanced sweetness and viscosity. The overall flavor profile gradually shifts backward. The overall extraction rate results show a sequential decrease, which aligns with predicted results.
Cause Analysis:
In pour-over drip brewing, bloom time, brewing time, and coffee bed temperature (i.e., actual brewing temperature) collectively influence the overall extraction rate and cannot be considered in isolation. In this series of experiments, the actual extraction time and coffee bed temperature had relatively significant impacts on the results.
Pour-over Experiment 2
(Second group of pour-over experiments: as bloom time extends, total brewing time is extended accordingly)
In the previous pour-over experiment, the total brewing time was fixed, meaning that when bloom time increased, actual extraction time decreased. The following experiment will explore the effects of blooming or not, and bloom duration, on brewing results when maintaining consistent pouring speed—meaning the actual extraction time remains the same across all groups.
Experiment Steps:
- Weigh 15g of coffee beans, grind with Fuji (ghost teeth) #2 and set aside
- Prepare sufficient 90°C hot water
- A: Add 15g of coffee grounds to a Hario V60 conical dripper, continuously pour 240g of hot water in circular motion, total brewing time is 1min58s
- B: Add 15g of coffee grounds to a Hario V60 conical dripper, first pour 40g of hot water for 20-second bloom, then pour 200g of hot water in circular motion over 1min38s, total brewing time is 1min58s
- C: Add 15g of coffee grounds to a Hario V60 conical dripper, first pour 40g of hot water for 40-second bloom, then pour 200g of hot water in circular motion over 1min38s, total brewing time is 2min18s
- D: Add 15g of coffee grounds to a Hario V60 conical dripper, first pour 40g of hot water for 60-second bloom, then pour 200g of hot water in circular motion over 1min38s, total brewing time is 2min38s
Experiment Results:
Results Analysis:
In this series of experiments, as bloom time increased, the changes in coffee flavor and mouthfeel followed similar trends to the previous experiment. For overall extraction rate, however, it first decreased then increased. This shows that: 1. As bloom time extends, it causes the coffee bed temperature to drop, affecting the actual extraction temperature and decreasing extraction efficiency; 2. It's evident that as bloom time extends and actual extraction time correspondingly lengthens, increased bloom time can, to some extent, increase extraction efficiency, with the increase compensating for or even exceeding the extraction efficiency loss caused by the drop in coffee bed temperature.
Practical Applications and Conclusion
We conducted these several groups of experiments to gain a more detailed understanding of blooming. If you're interested, you can actually do rough experiments when brewing coffee yourself, trying different bloom times to experience their effects on mouthfeel. Understanding these data and flavor changes can also be applied to your daily pour-over coffee brewing. If you want prominent acidity with forward-facing flavors, you might consider not blooming or using a short bloom time. If you want a balanced, solid mouthfeel, you might consider blooming for a longer period.
Many customers directly ask us how long to bloom when brewing coffee, how long to brew, and what water temperature to use. What we fear most is giving rigid, fixed rules or answers. There are so many varieties of coffee beans, and each roaster's style is so diverse—how could we possibly brew all beans with just one method? How boring! Of course, if you want to do that, it's not entirely impossible. We often say that good beans aren't limited by brewing methods, but while there are many methods, there's always one that's most suitable for that particular bean, or perhaps your favorite flavor profile. Trying more can be quite interesting.
Pour-over experiments have always been something we find quite challenging because there are too many variables—it's so exaggerated that even a breeze blowing nearby seems to affect its taste. We originally thought we could quickly organize this experiment following up on last time, but the result was that we had to repeat it several times!! Actually, repeating several times isn't a big deal—at worst, our operator Xiao Hei would be more tired, but the point is that after each brew, we still had to do sensory evaluations, drinking until we were dizzy. Before noon, the three of us were already wandering around the store in a daze! Fortunately, this is what we love! We also hope the resulting data will be useful to everyone.
Next, we'll continue to play seriously and rigorously, diving deep into the coffee world to explore thoroughly. If you have any questions or curiosities, you can raise them with us. As long as our equipment and resources allow, we'll try experiments to provide answers.
Experiment Credits
FrontStreet Coffee
Experiment Operation: Xiao Hei
Data Organization: Lao Lin
Text Editing: Jingjing
Shop Address: No. 10 Bao'an Qianjie, Dongshankou, Yuexiu District, Guangzhou - FrontStreet Coffee
Contact Phone: 020-38364473
Weibo: @前街咖啡 (FrontStreet Coffee)
Taobao Shop: 前街咖啡 (FrontStreet Coffee) http://taichancafe.taobao.com
Important Notice :
前街咖啡 FrontStreet Coffee has moved to new addredd:
FrontStreet Coffee Address: 315,Donghua East Road,GuangZhou
Tel:020 38364473
- Prev
Discover How to Identify Authentic Blue Mountain Coffee
1 Appearance Blue Mountain coffee's green beans are bluish-green in color, very uniform in appearance, medium to small in size, with slightly raised ends. They expand significantly in volume after roasting, becoming very full and plump. 2 Grinding True Blue Mountain coffee beans grow at high altitudes, giving them a relatively loose cellular structure. When ground by hand, they feel crisp, smooth, and consistent, without any
- Next
Costa Rica Yellow Honey Processed Roasted Coffee Beans - San Juan Yö Estate Villasarc Variety
Coffee Bean Details: Country: Costa Rica Grade: SHB Region: Central Valley Elevation: Average 1600 meters Processing Method: Yellow Honey Process (retaining 30% pulp) Variety: Villasarc
Related
- How to make bubble ice American so that it will not spill over? Share 5 tips for making bubbly coffee! How to make cold extract sparkling coffee? Do I have to add espresso to bubbly coffee?
- Can a mocha pot make lattes? How to mix the ratio of milk and coffee in a mocha pot? How to make Australian white coffee in a mocha pot? How to make mocha pot milk coffee the strongest?
- How long is the best time to brew hand-brewed coffee? What should I do after 2 minutes of making coffee by hand and not filtering it? How long is it normal to brew coffee by hand?
- 30 years ago, public toilets were renovated into coffee shops?! Multiple responses: The store will not open
- Well-known tea brands have been exposed to the closure of many stores?!
- Cold Brew, Iced Drip, Iced Americano, Iced Japanese Coffee: Do You Really Understand the Difference?
- Differences Between Cold Drip and Cold Brew Coffee: Cold Drip vs Americano, and Iced Coffee Varieties Introduction
- Cold Brew Coffee Preparation Methods, Extraction Ratios, Flavor Characteristics, and Coffee Bean Recommendations
- The Unique Characteristics of Cold Brew Coffee Flavor Is Cold Brew Better Than Hot Coffee What Are the Differences
- The Difference Between Cold Drip and Cold Brew Coffee Is Cold Drip True Black Coffee