Can Over-Extracted Coffee Be Diluted with Water? Should You Use Cold or Hot Water for Bypass?

Frequent café visitors may have experienced this: watching a barista prepare pour-over coffee, first circling water into the filter cup as usual, waiting for all the coffee liquid to drip into the lower pot, but instead of removing it, lifting the kettle again and pouring more water inside. This might make us wonder if the coffee was ruined, and water is being added to mask or weaken those negative flavors.

Today, FrontStreet Coffee will discuss what this practice of adding water after brewing coffee is all about, and what the purpose of this operation is.

Why add water to brewed coffee?

In fact, this seemingly unconventional operation has a specific term in the industry: "bypass," which translates to "旁路" (bypass path) in Chinese.

Simply put, when brewing water is poured directly onto coffee grounds, extracting soluble substances to create a flavorful coffee, this is the most common form of pour-over coffee in daily life, which we can call the "main path."

As the saying goes, "all roads lead to Rome." In coffee extraction, to make a delicious cup of coffee, besides the main path, we often use some bypass paths for intervention. But whether it's the main path or bypass, there's only one goal: to get a good-tasting cup of coffee.

For example, in the scenario mentioned at the beginning of this article by FrontStreet Coffee, the barista actually separates a portion of the planned water, then uses the remaining amount to extract a high-concentration coffee, and finally mixes the two evenly to create a coffee with moderate concentration and good taste. It's clear that the hot water added later didn't participate in the extraction process but directly went into the cup to play a dilution role. For this portion of hot water that didn't take the "main path," we call it "bypass water."

What is the use of bypass?

As an auxiliary element, bypass is actually widely applied in coffee extraction systems, and the "main path + bypass" combination often appears in the coffee we encounter in daily life.

Take the most common Americano as an example. The espresso extracted by the coffee machine is the "main path." Drinking it directly would be intensely bitter and stimulating, so it needs to be diluted with a certain proportion of hot water/room temperature water or ice to ensure the coffee maintains its positive aroma while providing drinkers with a palatable concentration. Obviously, the purpose of bypass (adding water) here is to adjust the coffee's concentration, and the bypass water also needs to be prepared in advance based on the flavor characteristics of the coffee beans.

Similarly, ice pour-over, which first uses hot water to extract a pot of high-concentration coffee and then uses ice cubes to cool and dilute it simultaneously, is also a very typical bypass approach. Taking FrontStreet Coffee's daily preparation of 1-2 servings with 15g of coffee grounds as an example, hot pour-over uses a 1:15 coffee-to-water ratio, while ice pour-over uses the formula "coffee grounds (fine grind) + 10x hot water + 5x ice cubes" for brewing. The ice cubes placed in the lower pot in advance are actually the "bypass" that didn't participate in extraction.

Besides adjusting concentration, many baristas also apply bypass to high-concentration, low-extraction brewing schemes to suppress the astringent, bitter, and miscellaneous substances that coffee grounds easily release in the final extraction stage. During operation, baristas consciously reduce the amount of water poured, lowering the extraction rate to reduce the release of negative flavors, and finally add water to dilute to an appropriate concentration, making the coffee flavor clearer and more comfortable to drink.

What other problems can bypass "rescue"?

Unlike the three planned scenarios above, bypass is also often applied to emergency situations that arise at the last moment, such as water pooling in the final stage or coffee being brewed too concentrated.

In the process of water washing over coffee grounds, small molecular acidic substances are released first, followed by sweet substances, and finally the larger bitter substances and miscellaneous parts that are more difficult to dissolve in water. When there are too many fine powders, they easily fall onto the filter paper with the agitation of water flow, blocking the water outlet gaps and causing the flow rate to slow down in the final stage. If we wait for all the hot water to finish flowing, not only will the extraction time be forcibly extended, but the smaller coffee particles are prone to over-extraction, producing bitter, woody, and miscellaneous flavors.

If our coffee brewing often exceeds 2 minutes and 10 seconds, and the taste consistently lacks aroma or has an unclean aftertaste, it's likely due to excessive soaking time. In this case, we might try removing the filter cup after 2 minutes, discarding the coffee liquid that won't come down, and then "rescue" it through bypass.

Another situation is when we follow the original framework for extraction, but the brewed coffee feels very thick and heavy overall, even somewhat cluttered—in short, making it difficult to distinguish flavors and lacking layering. The reason might be that during segmented water pouring, the flow rate wasn't well controlled, or the circling range (amplitude) was too small, causing the coffee grounds to accumulate at the bottom. This results in high coffee concentration, thick texture, and masks lighter aroma substances like some floral and fruity notes. In this case, we can add a little "bypass water" to help expand the flavor spectrum, allowing us to better perceive the flavors.

It's worth noting that since the bypass water in these two emergency situations is not part of the extraction plan, it's best to taste the brewed coffee first to check its concentration. If the taste is too strong, you can first add 5-10g of 75-80°C hot water to the pot, shake well, and then taste. Remember to add it multiple times in small amounts until it suits your taste.

Finally, there's another situation: if we find that the brewed coffee not only tastes strong but even has obvious bitterness, astringency, throat-catching discomfort, or other unpleasant aftertaste sensations, then this pot of coffee is likely over-extracted. In this case, you can follow the steps above to add a small amount of bypass water to try to weaken some negative flavors.

However, in FrontStreet Coffee's view, this approach ultimately treats symptoms rather than the root cause. If you want to brew good-tasting coffee, rather than relying on "adding water" at the end to rescue it every time, it's better to carefully identify the problem and correct it. This way, our learning will be twice as effective with half the effort.

- END -

Important Notice :

前街咖啡 FrontStreet Coffee has moved to new addredd:

FrontStreet Coffee Address: 315,Donghua East Road,GuangZhou

Tel:020 38364473