Which Coffee Beans Are Suitable for Iced Pour-Over? Does Black Coffee Taste Better Cold or Hot?

To enjoy freshly ground coffee during the National Day holiday, many customers came to the store to stock up and asked FrontStreet Coffee about problems they encountered in daily brewing. Among them, one customer said:

When she really likes a particular coffee bean, she experiences it through both hot pour-over and iced pour-over methods. She found that some coffee beans perform well when brewed hot, with both aroma and mouthfeel being excellent, but once made into iced (pour-over), they "fail." Besides each flavor not being as clear as in the hot version, the overall mouthfeel becomes very thin, sometimes even feeling like drinking water. Why is this?

How Different Are Hot and Iced Pour-Overs for Different Beans?

To get a relatively comprehensive comparison, FrontStreet Coffee selected 4 coffee beans with different styles for hot and iced pour-over extraction, then compared them in terms of aroma, flavor, and mouthfeel.

Washed Medium-Light Roast Representative: FrontStreet Coffee's Ethiopia Kaffa Forest

Hot Pour-Over Coffee: Obvious white floral and lemon aromas; flavors feature sugar orange, honey, grapefruit, and caramel notes, with high clarity and a mouthfeel as clear as green tea.

Iced Pour-Over Coffee: Weaker aroma, with only a faint layer of fruitiness; entry features green grapes, pear juice, and green tea's sweet and sour flavors, with lower body and a refreshing, cool mouthfeel.

Natural Process Medium-Light Roast Representative: FrontStreet Coffee's Panama Jenson Estate Geisha

Hot Pour-Over Coffee: Smells of obvious intense fruitiness and red floral aromas; flavors include cranberry, grape, pineapple, orange, Dahongpao tea, and clear fermentation notes, with a smooth entry and obvious juicy sensation.

Iced Pour-Over Coffee: Aroma performance similar to the previous group, overall weaker when smelled, dominated by citrus freshness; flavors include berries, dried fruits, and pineapple juice, with moderate fruit sweetness and a light texture.

Dark Roast Representative: FrontStreet Coffee's Indonesia Golden Mandheling

Hot Pour-Over Coffee: Aroma of caramel and chocolate; flavors include chocolate, nuts, spices, and caramel, very rich and aromatic; thick mouthfeel.

Iced Pour-Over Coffee: Roasted nut aroma, overall flavor profile of chocolate, herbal, and nutty notes, clean and single-dimensional. Mandheling's thick mouthfeel is not reflected in the iced pour-over.

Fermented Coffee Representative: FrontStreet Coffee's Colombia Finca Diviso Ombligon

Hot Pour-Over Coffee: Smells of intense orange and grape fruitiness with almond nuances; tastes include citrus, blackcurrant juice, black tea, spices, and fermented wine notes, with bright and solid fruit acids and very rich layers.

Iced Pour-Over Coffee: Still has obvious fermentation notes in aroma; tastes include fresh blueberry, pineapple, and sweet dried apricot flavors, with a rounded mouthfeel, overall like a chilled prune juice, with a hint of cinnamon in the aftertaste after swallowing.

Why Does Coffee Taste Good When Brewed Hot but Often Tastes Weak When Brewed Iced?

In reality, many coffees existed as hot versions before iced versions. For example, the universally known Americano existed as a hot beverage for a long time after its birth, and only later did an iced version gradually emerge to follow trends. The same goes for pour-over, which represents drip extraction. Hot pour-over existed much earlier than iced pour-over, and the equipment and brewing techniques that emerged in that era all evolved around hot brewing methods.

Typically, when acquiring a coffee bean, its flavor characteristics are first determined through cupping, then hot pour-over brewing parameters are constructed (generally combining roast level and processing method), while iced pour-over preparation methods are gradually built based on hot brewing.

The most common iced brewing operation involves adjusting the grind finer, reducing water amount, and appropriately modifying techniques on top of hot brewing to make high-concentration hot coffee, then rapidly cooling it with sufficient ice cubes, while using the melted ice water to reduce concentration, thus obtaining a cold drink that's strong enough and flavorful enough.

As FrontStreet Coffee shared during the summer's "universal formula," iced pour-over = coffee grounds (fine grind) + 10x hot water + 5x ice cubes. Here, the ice cubes are separated from the total water amount of the original hot pour-over (1:15 ratio), meaning the ice replaces part of the hot water that would have originally rinsed the grounds layer, then is separated individually, so it doesn't participate in the coffee extraction process.

With reduced water amount, the coffee's extraction range narrows accordingly, and substances concentrated in the later stages may not have time to release before water injection ends. These are precisely the main components that express sweetness, body, and aftertaste, which also leads to a gap in final flavor performance compared to hot pour-over.

Conclusion

From the above comparison, we can see that regardless of which coffee group, hot pour-over shows fuller aroma performance, and aspects like flavor complexity, layering, fruit sweetness, and solidity are all stronger than iced performance. Dark roast beans, which mainly feature caramel aromas, body, balance, and sweet aftertaste, particularly lose their charm in iced brewing.

However, iced pour-over does have one absolute advantage: it adds an icy sensation to the original coffee flavor, which is also an important reason why many people cannot give up cold drinks. Imagine enjoying a cool, refreshing beverage with rich aroma on a hot afternoon - what a pleasant experience that would be!

For this reason, we can leverage this advantage of iced pour-over to select suitable coffee beans for it. For example, medium-light roast coffees mainly have floral and fruity aromas, and the resulting iced coffee often appears somewhat light. In this case, we can prioritize natural process or fermented beans, allowing them to have both intense fruitiness or sweet-sour layers while maintaining a clean and light character.

- END -

Important Notice :

前街咖啡 FrontStreet Coffee has moved to new addredd:

FrontStreet Coffee Address: 315,Donghua East Road,GuangZhou

Tel:020 38364473